Should Professional Blood Donors be Jailed?

Submitted by lalithgparmar on

Professional blood donors may soon find themselves behind bars. According to the National Blood Transfusion Services Act 2007, being prepared by the Union health ministry, those donating blood in exchange for money may face rigorous imprisonment for three months and a hefty fine.

At present, even though buying and selling of blood is banned, thanks to a landmark Supreme Court judgment on January 1, 1996, the business of paid blood donation continues unabated.

According to a recent survey conducted by World Health Organisation, 52.42% of all blood donated in India is through voluntary blood donation camps. The figure was 45% in 2002. This shows that nearly 47.58% of all blood donated is either from paid donors or from family members.

Naco director general K Sujatha Rao, who heads the committee preparing the Act, told TOI, "Finalising the Act, which will look to completely wipe out paid blood donation, will take another 8-12 months. We have recently circulated a draft for comments from all stakeholders."

Speaking to TOI, Manmohan Lal Sarin, legal advisor to the Indian Society of Blood Transfusion and Immunohaematology, said this was a genuine lacuna in the law. Even though the SC banned paid donation, it did not stipulate any punishment, he said.

"Those involved in paid donation pose as relatives of the patient. Such people are threatened when caught or beaten up. But they can't be put in jail. According to the new Act coming up, such commercial donors will face a three-month jail term and a Rs 3,000 fine. The licences of blood banks will also be cancelled if found guilty," Sarin said.

According to Dr Debashish Gupta, NACO's national programme officer for blood safety, identifying a paid donor is simple. But unfortunately, hardly any blood banks screen volunteers giving blood, which is actually mandatory.

"There are ways to identify paid donors. They will have multiple puncture marks on their arm and low haemoglobin. That's because professionals donate every week while due to the timeframe required for iron replacement, donors are supposed to donate once every three months."

The Act also calls for the setting up of an independent Blood Transfusion Authority, to monitor the collection, storage, distribution and supply of safe blood in the country. At present, the drug controller general of India works as the regulatory body. Union health secretary Naresh Dayal said, "The legislation to bring blood collection and distribution under a single regulatory umbrella will be in place in a year's time. BTA will be an autonomous body."

Health minister A Ramadoss said BTA would help improve the quantity and quality of blood collected in India through voluntary donation. "The Act will provide punitive measures against those violating blood collection, storage and transfusion rules. Blood collection has to be voluntary. At present, donor screening is not carried out to eliminate paid donors. BTA will be functional in three years time," he said.



Submitted by rajat on Fri, 30-Nov-2007 - 00:32


This legislation comes as a good news to me. Next time I find a professional blood donor, I will have a clear idea of where I can take him and what will happen there. This may surely be a deterrent to professional donors and also gives meaning to the government's stand on professional blood donation.

As far as the govt policy is concerned, it sounds amazing! But but but.. anyone who has read the National blood safety action plan 2003 will have a serious doubt on these issues. The govt has in the past too drawn out flowery policies and decorated them in line with the best in the world, but reality bites!! Very few of the planks of the earlier policy are anywhere close to implementation and here is a new policy. I hope these administrators focus more on implementation of the known things rather that spend all the time in the world to find out what is the next right thing to be done.


Submitted by Naveen.R.K on Wed, 12-Dec-2007 - 16:13


No every one who donates blood for money should not be jailed bcz see some people will be there who are really in need of money,for their realtives operation or else they will be having some problems related to money,so what they will do is they donate blood and take money,What we call these persons as proffesional doners.......

We have to consider their problems also..........